I have a few questions for Patrick Grimm. One of them is as follows. What is a Jewish supremacist? Is that someone who believes that Judaism is the supreme religion? I ask this because I think anyone who has a religion thinks that their religion in supreme. For example, serious Catholics believe that Catholicism is the supreme religion. Wouldn’t that make them “Catholic supremacists”? Why, then, is it such an insult to call someone a “Jewish supremacist”? Why not just call them “Jews,” because every Jew is a Jewish supremacist, just as every Muslim is a Muslim supremacist, and every Christian is a Christian supremacist. Let’s look at your definition: Jewish supremacism is a worldwide global disease of opportunism by a band of Jewish psychopaths who have conned their way into positions of control, influence and dominion over the rest of us. This definition doesn’t make sense. If you are a psychopath, then you cannot properly live as a Jew. The Jewish lifestyle requires sanity, attentiveness, and intelligence. Furthermore, the only manner in which Jews would seek to exercize “control, influence, and dominion” over the Gentiles is to enforce the Seven Noahide Laws, which Jesus de facto sought to impose upon all humanity, except that Christians also want you to accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior. So what exactly don’t you like about the Seven Noahide laws? The part where people shouldn’t murder? The part where people shouldn’t steal? The part where there should be established courts of law? I find it puzzling that you would consider these rules bad, when Christians – which you are – essentially want the same thing from non-believers, except that Christians are a little less tolerant of disbelief, and would furthermore seek to have you believe that Jesus is the messiah. But Jews are still cool with Christians who are cool with Jews. So what exactly is your problem with Jews? Perhaps you didn’t get the memo which reads that there is a difference between Jews and pseudo-Jews. And I advise you read the memo before you continue to spout your mouth off about some of the most decent and righteous people on earth: real Jews. The second question I had was, does this “wonderful new woman who is also involved in this cause” also know of your reckless abuse of language? Has she also gotten the memo about the difference between Jews and Pseudo-Jews, which are further divisible into Zionists and Leftists? Do tell. I am curious to know. Surely a woman of honor does not appreciate a man who bashes the innocent right along with the guilty, just because they have similar-sounding last names.
1 response so far ↓
zionistwatch // October 15, 2008 at 11:43 pm |
You raise some interesting questions, but it seems your mind is already made up when it comes to both the Jewish Question and to my own body of work, which is substantial. I say this because you make many leaps and numerous assumptions that do not gel with the reality of what I have written. I have one question for you. How many of my essays have you actually read? I would guess you have perused very few of my nearly 200 articles posted on Zionist Watch.
Wow. 200 articles. Is this supposed to intimidate me? This paragraph reminds me of Chong Li in the movie Bloodsport. He would flex his pec’s and snort before a fight in order to intimidate his opponent. Well, I must say: your efforts to intimidate me are less than successful.
Let me be frank and perhaps a little harsh with you. To call you both ignorant and naïve about the facts of Jewish supremacism is not mere hyperbole. It is fact. You ask me in a tone that is rife with rhetorical sarcasm “What is a Jewish supremacist? Is that someone who believes that Judaism is the supreme religion? I ask this because I think anyone who has a religion thinks that their religion in supreme. For example, serious Catholics believe that Catholicism is the supreme religion. Wouldn’t that make them “Catholic supremacists”? Why, then, is it such an insult to call someone a “Jewish supremacist”? Why not just call them “Jews,” because every Jew is a Jewish supremacist, just as every Muslim is a Muslim supremacist, and every Christian is a Christian supremacist.”
Again, you remind me of a movie. There is a line in the movie Other People’s Money in which Danny DeVito says something like, “I hate it when people say, ‘let me be frank, because that means they weren’t frank to begin with.’”
Setting aside the obvious fact that most Jews are NOT RELIGIOUS and are atheists and that in Israel 80% of Jews believe in no god whatsoever, yet still believe they have a Divine Right to the land of others, you seem to have a gross misunderstanding of the Jewish religion, treating it as any other faith. Wrong answer.
Your definition of a Jew is false, unless you are a Jew. In other words, unless you are precisely the kind of person whom you foolishly bash on this blog – a real Jew who goes by Torah, including Talmud – you have no good reason to define a Jew as someone who comes from a Jewish mother. Rather, that is the JEWISH definition of a Jew. That comes from JUDAISM. In fact, let’s play a game. Let’s see who knows more about Judaism. I will give you 24 hours to tell me what part or parts of the Torah are cited by the rabbis to define a Jew as someone who comes from a Jewish mother. And I will give you a generous one week (168 hours) to find the tractate in the Talmud – not even the chapter, but the tractate – from which discussion of the definition of a Jew is derived. We shall see, at the end of this “sparring” session, who is the one with a “gross misunderstanding of Judaism.”
Anyway, I say to you, once again, that your definition of a Jew as someone who is born into it comes from the Jewish religion, and unless you practice the Jewish religion, you have no good reason to define a Jew in that way. Rather, as a Gentile, you ought to define a Jew as someone who practices the Jewish religion. Therefore, 80% of Israelis are not Jews, because they do not practice the Jewish religion, if your statistic is correct, which it probably is. I agree that most Israelis are Gentiles, practitioners of Leftist Zionist atheism. That is their philosophy; not Judaism.
If you question why you ought to define a Jew as someone who practices the Jewish religion, I would be more than happy to answer it. But atheism is the opposite of what the Jewish religion advocates. In case you have forgotten, monotheism derives from Judaism. That is where the belief in God comes from. So for you to imply that you can be a Jew and an atheist at the same time is for you to show the world that you don’t know the first thing about Judaism. Let me teach you something. Judaism is all about God and believing in God.
What is a Jewish supremacist? It is someone who believes that in any relationships with Gentiles or non-Jews, Jews should be in control.
The Jews don’t want to be in control. In fact, the Jews are the least interested in converting other people to their religion. The Christians, and more so the Muslims, have sought to convert others to their religions by the sword. The Jews have been the most peaceful advocates of their religion, especially in modern times. They do not seek control; they seek freedom from persecution. I’m not talking about pseudo-Jews (Leftist Zionists); I’m talking about real Jews.
If a white person wanted to subjugate and control blacks, you would call that person a white supremacist without any reservations, wouldn’t you?
A white supremacist is someone who believes the white race is supreme; not someone who advocates slavery over Afric people. The Jews don’t want to enslave the Gentiles. To the contrary, it is the Catholic Church and the Muslims who have enslaved the Jews by putting them in ghettos and having them pay a special “Jew tax.” The Jews are the most reasonable people in the world, on average, and slavery is an unreasonable institution. Judaism is a pro-freedom religion. The Noahide Laws are a bill of rights for human liberty.
My friend,
So we’re friends now, huh?
Judaism can only loosely be called a religion at all and for most Jews it is closer to a racial cult that enforces the superiority and dominance of the Jewish people over every other people.
Um, you can convert to Judaism. You can’t convert to another race. And again, every religious cult believes that their religion is superior to every other religion. The only difference is that, whereas a Catholic or a Muslim believes you are going to hell or you deserve to be punished by death if you do not believe in Jesus or Mohammad, in Judaism, you can be viewed as a “righteous Gentile” who is going to heaven, without being a Jew, but by following seven simple rules that Jesus himself advocated. The following is from Wikipedia:
1. Prohibition of Idolatry: You shall not have any idols before God.
2. Prohibition of Murder: You shall not murder. (Genesis 9:6)
3. Prohibition of Theft: You shall not steal.
4. Prohibition of Sexual Promiscuity: You shall not commit adultery.
5. Prohibition of Blasphemy: You shall not blaspheme God’s name.
6. Dietary Law: Do not eat flesh taken from an animal while it is still alive. (Genesis 9:4)
7. Requirement to have just Laws: You shall set up an effective judiciary to enforce the preceding six laws fairly.
Now tell me, Mr. Grimm. Which religion is more civilized? One which chops your head off and says you’re going to hell if you don’t believe that a guy named “Jesus” walked on water 2000 years ago? Or a religion that considers you a moral human being, worthy of life and liberty, for following seven simple rules that America’s Founding Fathers would surely agree with?
This is not wide-eyed conspiracy theory. This attitude is repeated again and again in the Old Testament and takes on a more domineering and dangerous tone in the Babylonian Talmud. Doesn’t it puzzle you why most Jews are atheists, yet still remain Jews, some of whom still attend their local synagogue. There are even atheist rabbis practicing the Jewish “religion”.
Again, you are ignorant of the Jewish religion. Judaism requires belief in a God. It’s one of the Ten Commandments. Now here’s another quiz for you. You say know about the Jewish religion. I will give you a week to tell me how many actual Jewish commandments are in the so-called “Ten Commandments.” Considering that you claim to know more about the Jewish religion than me, this should be a fairly easy question for you to answer.
If you are not able to answer these questions that I have put forth, then I have little reason to continue this sparring match, for I would be above your weight class. If you demonstrate that you are not the lightweight you present yourself to be, then we can proceed with this duel.